Metamask sued by SEC, where will Web3 go? | TrendX Research Institute

07/01/2024·6months ago

Just as everyone was still focusing on the final decision of the SEC (U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission) on ETH ETF, the SEC made a sudden move on June 29, formally suing Consensys, a blockchain technology company and also the parent company of Metamask, accusing MetaMask's Swap and staking products of violating securities laws, and specifically naming Lido and Rocket Pool's liquid staking tokens stETH and rETH as unregistered "securities".

This news has caused a stir in the industry. According to TrendX sentiment index data, the sentiment index of Lido and Metamask has dropped significantly. Lido's sentiment index has dropped by 30, from 21 to a low of -9; Metamask's sentiment index has dropped by over 100, from the original 33 to a plummeting -69, and the sentiment has changed from relatively positive to extremely negative.

The drop in sentiment has also caused price fluctuations. According to Coinmarketcap data, on the day the SEC filed the lawsuit, Lido's price dropped from a high of $2.43 to a low of $1.86, a decrease of over 23%.

As the Metamask wallet, which has the highest user penetration in the web3 industry, and Lido, which plays a crucial role in the ETH Stake & Restake sector, are sued, it will undoubtedly cast a shadow over their project development and the development of the entire industry.

ConsenSys vs. SEC: A long-standing legal dispute

On Thursday, April 25, 2024, ConsenSys, a blockchain technology company, filed a lawsuit against the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) for attempting to classify Ethereum (ETH) as a security in the Northern District of Texas. This event has attracted widespread attention. In the lawsuit documents, ConsenSys pointed out that the SEC is trying to regulate ETH as a security, despite the fact that ETH does not possess the characteristics of a security, and the SEC has previously stated that ETH is not a security and is not within the SEC's statutory jurisdiction.

Origin of the event

On April 10, 2024, SEC staff sent ConsenSys a "Wells Notice," stating that they were about to recommend that the Commission take enforcement action against ConsenSys for violating federal securities laws through its MetaMask Swaps and MetaMask Staking products. A Wells Notice is a formal notice issued by the SEC to inform individuals or entities under investigation that the SEC intends to recommend enforcement action for alleged violations of securities laws. This notice allows the recipient to provide written or oral statements, explanations, or rebuttals of the SEC's preliminary findings before the SEC makes a final decision.

Focus of the lawsuit

The SEC's legal basis is that MetaMask's related Swap and other functions involve unregistered securities transactions, thereby violating federal securities laws. ConsenSys' argument is that the SEC's stance on whether these tokens should be considered securities is ambiguous, and therefore they decided to file a lawsuit with the court. ConsenSys believes that Ethereum should not be considered a security, and MetaMask's functions do not involve securities transactions, and therefore do not violate federal securities laws. SEC's lawsuits are typically based on several aspects:

Unregistered securities issuance: SEC may accuse Consensys of not following the registration requirements of U.S. securities laws in the issuance process of certain tokens. Under U.S. law, any asset considered a security must be registered with the SEC before issuance, or meet certain exemption conditions.
Misleading investors: SEC may claim that Consensys misled or failed to provide adequate disclosure to investors during its token issuance process, leading to investors not fully understanding the risks and nature of the investment.

Impact and concerns

If the court rules that Ethereum is a security, then the sale of Ethereum in the United States will need to follow procedures similar to stocks, which will have a significant impact on exchanges and institutions holding large amounts of Ethereum, and will also affect the approval of Ethereum ETFs. ConsenSys believes that the SEC's illegal usurpation of power over ETH will bring disaster to the Ethereum network and ConsenSys.

The lawsuit against Consensys by the SEC may have wide-ranging effects:

Impact on Consensys: If the SEC's allegations are upheld, Consensys may face substantial fines, compensation for investor losses, and requirements to reform its business model. This will have a significant impact on the company's operations and reputation.
Impact on the crypto industry: This lawsuit may become a significant event in the industry, indicating that the SEC is enforcing stricter regulations on cryptocurrency and blockchain companies. This may prompt other companies in the industry to re-examine the compliance of their business and encourage more companies to work with the SEC to avoid similar legal risks.
Market reaction: This event may cause short-term fluctuations in the cryptocurrency market, especially for projects and tokens related to Consensys. Investors may be concerned about regulatory risks, affecting market sentiment.

Escalating contradictions

In earlier lawsuits, ConsenSys expressed doubts about the SEC, and on June 18, the SEC gave an ambiguous statement: "While we do not agree with the facts or legal conclusions stated in the June 4 letter in this notice or in any other respect, based on the information available to us as of the date of this notice, we do not intend to recommend enforcement action against ConsenSys Software Inc." However, this statement does not mean that the SEC has abandoned its investigation of ConsenSys.

Statement from legal counsel

Regarding this lawsuit, ConsenSys' legal counsel Laura Brookover stated that the entire investigation (not just against ConsenSys) has ended. The letter indicated that no charges would be brought against ConsenSys, but this does not mean that charges will not be brought against others who provide or sell Ethereum.

Different viewpoints

However, there are also opponents who believe that the SEC's letter did not explicitly state that the investigation had "ended." For example, David Barrera, founder of Enumma, believes that this only means that the SEC will not bring charges against others who provide or sell Ethereum, but according to the SEC's enforcement manual, the conclusion of the investigation does not mean that the investigation is completely over.

Industry impact

Currently, it seems that the SEC's lawsuit against ConsenSys has become a foregone conclusion, but industry observers are more concerned about whether this will affect Liquid Staking and Restaking, as well as the final approval of the ETH ETF. Laura believes that the SEC's investigation into these activities is part of a separate investigation and does not affect the conclusion of the Ethereum 2.0 investigation.

Conclusion

Although more details about this lawsuit have yet to be disclosed, it is certain that the integration of Web3 with the real world is becoming increasingly close, and relevant policies or regulatory bodies are finding it difficult to exclude Web3. In this regard, we should have full confidence.

The conflict between the SEC and ConsenSys reflects the complexity of the cryptocurrency industry in terms of law and regulation. As more regulations and policies are put in place, finding a balance between innovation and compliance will be an important challenge for the entire industry. We look forward to the final outcome of this case and hope that it will provide beneficial insights for the healthy development of the industry.

Follow us at TrendX

TrendX is a leading AI-driven Web3 trend tracking and intelligent trading platform globally, aiming to be the preferred platform for the next billion users entering the Web3 field. By combining multidimensional trend tracking and intelligent trading, TrendX provides a comprehensive experience of project discovery, trend analysis, primary investment, and secondary trading.

Website: https://app.trendx.tech/

Twitter: https://twitter.com/TrendX_tech

Investment carries risks, projects are for reference only, please bear the risks yourself